This is a difficult story for everyone involved, most certainly the patients and their families and physicians, as well as many hundreds of ex-employees and volunteers, donors and creditors.
It is a difficult story to report…like chasing chickens…particularly when transparency doesn’t appear to be a value embraced by the current regime. Local reporters must rely on the Freedom of Information Act to get past the obfuscation of the spokesman for the distressed organization.
Jul 1, 2010 –
The Board Chairman announces the appointment of a former public relations and fundraising functionary with the San Diego Hospice Foundation as President and Chief Executive Officer, succeeding Jan Cetti who has retired after 14 years at the helm of SDHIMC
Feb, 2011 –
A team of 8 Medicare auditors spend 5 days on site reviewing 149 charts of patients admitted to service between 1/1/09 and 11/30/10, the results of which are, more than 2 years hence, yet to be disclosed, according to CEO Pacurar.
Sept, 14 – Sept 22, 2011 –
A team of 4 surveyors arrive from the CA Dept of Public health arrive to conduct a routine Medicare re-certification survey. Initially 20 patients are sampled. The survey which lasts 8 days includes home visits to 5 patients. Nine deficiencies are cited including agency leadership for failure to assure reporting of Adverse Events including errors in the use of a Computer-aided Drug Delivery (CADD) pump resulting in a patient receiving 5x the prescribed dose of morphine sulfate. In the course of the survey the agency spontaneously reports two additional similar recent events. The survey sample is amended to include these patients. According to the survey:
The facility failed to implement immediate corrective actions to prevent reoccurrence of CADD pump (continuous ambulatory delivery device used to deliver narcotic analgesia) narcotic overmedication incidents, after the first incident on 8/7/11. Within 40 days of the first incident, 2 more patients were involved in CADD pump narcotic overdose incidents. The Vice President of Inpatient & Nursing Services and the Manager of Pharmacy were notified of an Immediate Jeopardy on 9/16/11 at 5:05P.M.
Less than two hours after the Immediate Jeopardy designation, the Vice President of Inpatient & Nursing Services.presents a 7-point plan of correction. Surveyors respond favorably and the Immediate Jeopardy is abated at 6:40 P.M.
State surveyors return to verify implementation of the Plan of Correction
A senior official of the Survey and Certification Division of Medicare writes:
Contrary to your allegations of correction, however, this resurvey, completed on December 12,2011, documented your continued noncompliance with Federal health and safety requirements. More specifically, as detailed on the enclosed the Statement of Deficiencies (Form CMS2567), the contents of which are incorporated by reference herein, the survey completed on December 12, 2011, documented deficiencies that, on balance, reasonably support a conclusion…of continued noncompliance with Federal health and safety requirements”.
Medicare lifts its decertification warning, as a result of a revised Plan of Correction, which perhaps includes engagement of an outside clinical compliance team. It is unknown whether a formal Medicare Compliance Plan exists, or if this represents the advent of such.
Pacurar implements a patient care staff retraining program, presumably in response to the findings reported by the outside clinical review team she has engaged.
A moratorium on patient admissions is imposed for a weekend
In apparently the first press report(s) (SD Union Times) of the organization’s distress, several almost contradictory claims are attributed to President and Chief Executive Officer Pacurar.
o Although post payment audit results are still unknown, Pacurar said she believes there will be enough financial pain to require layoffs of up to 200 of the hospice’s 870 employees. “The organization, after the first of the year, will look different than it does today,” Pacurar said. “It will be smaller. It will focus solely on the great care of hospice patients.”
o Pacurar said she believes the hospice is vulnerable to millions in rebates to Medicare because the program has not been strict enough in making sure that its patients are truly suffering from an illness likely to cause death within six months. She said doctors and care givers operated for decades on an “open access” policy that kept patients on hospice care for longer than six months, sometimes without being able to demonstrate that their condition was worsening.
o The executive said she also dismissed the hospice’s previous chief medical officer (also the Chief Financial Officer…reported elsewhere) and instituted a new compliance department that will regularly audit patient charts before requesting payment from Medicare.
o It remains to be seen, she said, how much of that amount the federal government will want back. At first, officials said they worried that the number could be as high as 60 percent. However, a recent conversation with a Medicare official gave them hope to believe any rebate will not be so high that it will cripple the operation.“I’m quite excited about moving forward. I have recently added new leadership to help me execute the plan that we’ve developed to take us through this difficult time,” she said
o Within weeks of that report, Medicare notifies the organization they will be subject to 100% pre-payment claims review, but that decision is almost immediately revised to 100% post payment claims review is instituted; serious payment interruption is averted
In a December meeting of the Board of Directors, the month-old Hospice Chief Operating Officer, who as subsequently revealed in a Bankruptcy Court deposition has no operational health care experience, much less hospice, presents an "analysis" to the Board of Directors and the CEO, ostensibly a strategic plan that features two very grim options: (a.) continue to operate as best as possible, under intensified regulatory scrutiny and possible financial damage as may potentially result from the Medicare audits, repair the organization and maintain the 35 year-old mission or (b.) accept the second option which the gentleman admits he favors: Shut it down…
San Diego Hospice and Palliative Care Corporation files Chapter 11. Subsequent reports reveal the Board of Directors decision made in December to close the organization. Reports also cite some type of affiliation arrangement with Scripps Memorial Hospital that provides (a.) SDHIPC a $5M operating loan, (b.) an offer to purchase SDHIPC-owned real estate for $10.7M subject to bankruptcy court approval (c.) absorption of remaining employees as well as (d.) patients (subject to Scripps qualification of eligibility) into a small (2012 unduplicated census: 86 patients), for-profit, licensed and certified hospice in Poway, which Scripps has acquired in the preceding days and weeks.
Mar 12, 2013 –
Deposition of San Diego Hospice & Institute of Palliative Care Chief Operations Officer: